Mathew Newman
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Mathew Newman
Partner
Guernsey
In appropriate circumstances, the Guernsey Court can strike out all or part of a party's claim or defence, avoiding the time and costs involved in pursuing a case that cannot properly proceed.
In this article, Ogier's Dispute Resolution experts examine the grounds for strike out applications in Guernsey, the principles established by the courts and the strategic considerations for parties bringing or defending an application.
A strike out application is an application by a party asking the Court to strike out all or part of another party's claim or defence without the matter proceeding to trial. It therefore offers an alluring result, but care should be taken and specialist advice obtained as "there is a heavy burden on [a strike out] applicant because the respondent has to provide comparatively little in respect of his case to avoid the consequences of a cause being struck out".
Rule 52 (2) of the Royal Court Civil Rules 2007 gives the Court the power to strike out all or a part of a pleading. The decision to strike out is discretionary. There are four grounds for striking out a pleading:
that the pleading discloses no reasonable grounds for bringing or defending an action
that the pleading is an abuse of the Court's process or is otherwise likely to obstruct the just disposal of the proceedings
that there has been a failure to comply with a rule, practice direction or court order
there is a want of prosecution
The most recent Guernsey authority on strike out is Attard v Overseas Trust and Pension Limited (civil number 2201) (Attard), in which the Court confirmed that the relevant principles were those set out in Tranquility Holdings v Invista Real Estate Investment Management (CI) Limited (Guernsey Judgment 38/2015) (Tranquility):
“Claims which are suitable for striking out … include those which raise an unwinnable case where continuance of the proceedings is without any possible benefit to the respondent and would waste resources on both sides“
“The principal test is whether the party's case is 'bound to fail', which creates a high threshold before a pleading, or a part thereof, will be struck out. Simply because a case might be weak is not sufficient to justify striking out“
“A statement of case is not suitable for striking out if it raises a serious issue of fact which can only be properly determined by hearing oral evidence"
“Where a statement of case is found to be defective, the court should consider whether that defect might be cured by amendment and, if it might be, the Court should refrain from striking it out without first giving the party concerned an opportunity to amend”
“The Court may strike out, as an abuse of the court's process, particulars of claim which are so badly drafted that they fail to reveal to the defendant, or to the Court, the case the defendant can expect to meet at trial. However, proof of bad drafting is not sufficient on its own. The Court should not strike out the particulars without first giving the claimant an opportunity to amend“
The purpose of the particulars of claim were explained by Moore-Bick LJ in Credit Suisse AG v Arabian Aircraft & Equipment Leasing Co [2014] CP Rep 4: “Particulars of claim are intended to define the claim being made. They are a formal document prepared for the purposes of legal proceedings and can be expected to identify with care and precision the case the claimant is putting forward. They must set out the essential allegations of fact on which the claimant relies and which he will seek to prove at trial, but they should also state the nature of the case that is to be made in order to inform the defendant and the court of the basis on which it is said the facts give rise to a right to the remedy being claimed”
"It is not appropriate to strike out a claim in an area of developing jurisprudence since, in such areas, decisions as to novel points of law should be based on actual findings of fact”
The Ogier Disputes Resolution team have acted in many of the key authorities on strike out applications, including:
Jakob International Inc v HSBC Private Bank (CI) Limited (26/20616): the then-Bailiff set out just how high the threshold is for applications of this kind. The applicant party is required to demonstrate that the claims made are "unarguable, bound to fail or unwinnable" considering those terms "as interchangeable"
Providence Investment Funds PCC Ltd v Pricewaterhousecoopers CI LLP [2020] GRC021: the Court provided guidance on the importance of allowing amendments where this would remedy rather than strike out and of the further caution required before striking out a claim which involved a new area of law: "Where a pleading is defective and can be remedied by being re-pleaded, the approach is to refrain from striking out the action because that opportunity to re-plead should be given… This is not an action that is unwinnable or bound to fail if the defect in the pleading can be rectified by amendment. If there is to be any sanction, that can sound in costs rather than depriving the Plaintiff of its ability to pursue its case". He also rejected the application because, "it is inappropriate to do so in an area of developing jurisprudence without basing that conclusion on actual findings of fact," reinforcing the final point in Tranquility
Lucille Holdings PTE Ltd v HSBC Management (Guernsey) Limited & Another [2024] GRC 006: the Deputy Bailiff at the time considered that a new or developing area of law makes a claim unsuitable for strike out: "Whilst I have found that the current pleadings do not disclose a reasonable cause of action, I have decided that due to the developments in this jurisdiction, the Plaintiff should be given an opportunity to amend its pleadings"
In Landl & Ors v Hogg & Ors [2024] GRC010, LB Marshall KC applied the Tranquility principles to strike out the Plaintiff’s cause in its entirety, noting that such a course of action was "amply justified as an exercise of my powers under RCCR r52(2)(b), to strike out a pleading on the grounds that it is “likely to obstruct the just disposal of the proceedings…” The opacity of the various claims made in this single cause had had just that effect.
In Attard, the Judge agreed with the Defendant that the Plaintiff's cause was deficient in that failed to set out the alleged loss and causation. However, applying Tranquility, the question was whether the defect could be cured by amendment and if so, whether the court should refrain from striking it out without first giving the Plaintiff an opportunity to amend. The Judge concluded that: "the Plaintiff should be afforded the opportunity to amend the Cause to cure the defect, namely, to plead the precise loss and causation". The strike out application was therefore refused.
A strike out application is not a shortcut by which to ask the Judge which case they prefer. Its purpose is to prevent Court time and resource being spent on legally defective cases that cannot properly proceed.
The burden of establishing abuse rests on the party alleging it, and the threshold is a high one. In Attard, the Applicant asked the Court to dispose of the Plaintiff’s claim on the basis that it was an abuse of the Court’s processes and only served to waste the parties’ time and costs if it was permitted to continue.
In Rawlinson & Hunter Trustees SA v Investec Trust (Guernsey) Ltd [2016] GJ 43/2016 (CoA), the Guernsey Court of Appeal placed reliance on the relevant English authorities when considering applications to strike out a pleading for abuse of process, given the identical wording in CPR r.3.4 (2)(b).
Examples of abuse include claims which are "vexatious, scurrilous or obviously ill-founded" (CPR PD 3A). This ground concerns the proper use of the Court process and can apply beyond cases where there is simply a legal defect in the claim. There is not a closed list or category of circumstances that will amount to an abuse. The Court will consider each case on its particular facts.
Although the Court has an unqualified discretion to strike out a statement of case if there has been a failure to comply with a rule, practice direction or court order, there is no presumption that the discretion will be exercised. Repeated failures by a claimant to comply with Court orders where those failures render it impossible for the defendant to prepare for trial may suffice.
Instead of striking out, the Court may exercise its wide powers under Rule 50, for example, to vary the time allowed for a party to comply with an order. The Court can also make an "unless" order under rule 53, with the sanction that non-compliance with its order means a party's pleading will be struck out.
This is a ground which applies only against a Plaintiff (or the defendant on a counterclaim). The case of Ogier v Grand Havre Holdings Limited (2007-08) GLR N15, CoA provides useful guidance. The test is "whether the delay had been inordinate, inexcusable and prejudicial to the defendant". In that case there had been a delay of 11 years since the Claimant commenced the action, and any trial would have taken place some 17 years after the relevant events. Given extensive oral evidence would have been required, the delay created a substantial risk of an unfair trial.
Ogier regularly advises clients on strike out applications and their place within the wider litigation strategy. Tactical judgment and an understanding of the case as a whole are just as important as identifying the legal basis for the application. The existence of a potential ground for strike out is only the beginning of the analysis; what are the prospects of success? What are the risks? How is the other party likely to respond? What will the application actually achieve? Is it sensible to make an application on the particular facts of the case? Is it commercially justified?
There is a lot to consider:
timing: when is the best time to make an application for strike out?
risk: what are the risks of making an application, not just in terms of costs, but also the wider litigation risk. Could the application, for example, prompt an amendment to the case which ultimately makes the claim against you stronger? Might you expose arguments earlier than necessary or strategically desirable?
other applications: what about applying for summary judgment, which is closely linked? Should you make both applications, and if so should they be made at the same time?
defending: what if you are on the receiving end of a strike out application? Although the burden rests on the applicant, careful thought must be given to the steps required to protect and defend your case. Are there any evidential steps you need to take? Can any alleged defect be cured by amendment? Should an application to amend be made and if so, when?
Ogier's Dispute Resolution team in Guernsey has extensive experience acting for clients in civil litigation, including bringing and defending strike out applications.
If you have any queries or need further assistance in relation to any of the issues raised in this article, please contact a member of the team.
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up