Mathew Newman
Partner | Legal
Guernsey
Mathew Newman
Partner
Guernsey
This can happen where trustees are deadlocked or face a disabling conflict of interest that prevents them from acting impartially.
In this article, Ogier's trust dispute experts in Guernsey consider when a trustee may surrender its discretion and the factors the Royal Court is likely to consider when deciding whether to accept it.
This is the fifth of a series of short articles summarising key aspects of trusts law in Guernsey. See our earlier articles:
Trustee blessing applications in Guernsey: what trustees need to know
Removing a trustee in Guernsey: key considerations and upcoming changes to the law
Gross negligence and trustee liability in Guernsey: update on key principles and case law
Why arbitration may become an increasingly attractive way to resolve Guernsey trust disputes
Guernsey law follows the English law principles established in the landmark case of Public Trustee v Cooper [2001] WTLR 901, as confirmed by the Guernsey Court of Appeal in Re F (judgment 32 / 2016).
There are four categories of Public Trustee v Cooper application:
Category 1: whether the proposed action is within the trustee's powers
Category 2: blessing a momentous decision
Category 3: surrender of discretion
Category 4: attack on exercise of trustee's powers, whereby the trustee seeks an order approving a decision it has already taken
This article is focused on Category 3: the surrender of the trustee's discretion to the Court.
When a trustee surrenders its discretion, the trustee stops making the decision itself. Instead, the Royal Court of Guernsey steps into the shoes of the trustee and exercises its own discretion to decide what is in the best interests of the trust and its beneficiaries.
The courts are usually hesitant to step into the shoes of a trustee, with such applications generally kept for situations of genuine impasse, unmanageable conflict of interest or where any decision the trustee makes would inherently favour one group of beneficiaries or investors to the detriment of another. This creates an unavoidable perception of bias.
The difference from more common blessing applications is that in the latter the trustee retains and exercises its own discretion and asks the Court to bless the trustee's decision. In a Category 3 application, the trustee surrenders the decision making to the Court and asks the Court to determine what should be done.
The Court will not automatically accept a surrendered discretion.
In the Guernsey case of Kleinwort Benson (Guernsey) Limited v Aras Investment Management Limited [2015 GLR72], the Royal Court granted a category three blessing application on the basis that it was a well-established principle that a trustee faced with a conflict of interest that "disables" it from acting may surrender its discretion to the Court.
Here, the Royal Court was satisfied on the facts that this was an appropriate case for the trustee to surrender its discretion given:
that any decision taken by the trustee would have the effect of favouring one group of investors at the expense of another group
that the trustee was in a situation where, if it were to take a decision on these issues there would be a perception, or a real risk of a perception, that it was acting in its own interests
The Court therefore agreed to make the necessary decision in place of the trustee.
At paragraph 25 of the judgment, the Guernsey Court cited with approval the following passage from Lewin on Trusts (18th edition) that summarises the position as a matter of English law: "Where the trustees surrender their discretion to the court, it acts in their place by giving directions. In doing so, the court will act as a reasonable trustee could be expected to act having regard to all the material circumstances and is not bound by the wishes of any beneficiary. The court has, however, no general powers [other] than the trustees have either under the trust instrument or under the general law."
The Cayman Islands Court more recently at first instance also accepted the accuracy of the above paragraph from Lewin in HSBC International Trustee Limited v Tan Poh Lee and Ors FSD 175 of 2019 (IKJ), an identical reference now being to paragraph 27-083 of the 19th edition.
In the leading English Category 3 decision in AB v CD [2019] WTLR 1083, the trustees (a professional trustee and lay co-trustees) became fundamentally deadlocked and unable to reach unanimity regarding the exercise of their discretionary powers concerning the distribution of a discretionary trust fund.
In its judgment, the English High Court reiterated that the surrender of discretion is treated as a last resort and the judiciary is generally reluctant to accept a surrender and will typically tell trustees to reconsider. However, in this instance, because the deadlock threatened proper trust administration, the High Court took the rare step of intervening to exercise the discretionary power itself to break the impasse.
While both cases are not binding on the Guernsey Court, they are likely to be taken into consideration by the Guernsey Court when considering future Category 3 applications.
The Jersey Court of Appeal in Representation of SG Kleinwort Hambros Trust (CI) Limited and Others [2023] JCA 088 neatly summarised judicial intervention in category 3 cases in the following extract:
36: "The non-intervention principle is an expression that has been coined as a convenient label to describe the court’s approach to the exercise of its supervisory jurisdiction over trusts. It is reflected in the nature of the test applied by the Court in Category 2 cases. It is also reflected in the fact that the court is not bound to accept a surrender in Category 3 cases. It is similarly reflected in the approach the court takes in exercise of what in England & Wales is referred to as the rule in Hastings-Bass: see Pitt v. Holt [2013] 2 AC 108."
37: "In using the expression non-intervention principle, it is important to keep two considerations firmly in mind. First, it is a convenient label to describe the court’s general approach. It is not a rule of law, nor is it inflexible. Second, what is meant by saying that the court will in general not intervene in the management of a trust is that the Court will in general not direct fiduciaries how to exercise their discretionary powers."
38: "There are good reasons of policy and practicality to justify the non-intervention principle. The designated decisionmaker in a trust is the trustee. The settlor does not choose the court as the trustee. Rather, he chooses his appointed trustee: S v. L, at §22. The Court would not normally claim to have any more expertise or knowledge of the particular dynamics of any individual trust than the trustees, and quite possibly less: Re F Charitable Trust [2017] (2) JLR 26, at §12. If the Court were to take its own decision, it would encourage every disappointed beneficiary to come to court in the hope of a more favourable outcome: Representation of the C Trust, at §109."
Although Category 3 cases are unusual, the above cases summarising successful applications are a helpful reminder for Guernsey trustees that in appropriate circumstances consideration should be given as to whether such an application should be made.
Ogier's Dispute Resolution team in Guernsey has extensive experience advising trustees, beneficiaries and other parties in all categories of Public Trustee v Cooper applications. For advice on any of the issues raised by this article, contact our experts via the details below.
Ogier is a professional services firm with the knowledge and expertise to handle the most demanding and complex transactions and provide expert, efficient and cost-effective services to all our clients. We regularly win awards for the quality of our client service, our work and our people.
This client briefing has been prepared for clients and professional associates of Ogier. The information and expressions of opinion which it contains are not intended to be a comprehensive study or to provide legal advice and should not be treated as a substitute for specific advice concerning individual situations.
Regulatory information can be found under Legal Notice
Sign up to receive updates and newsletters from us.
Sign up